
Why Role Play Works in Coaching Training and How to Make It Real
Few managers look forward to role play. Yet when we asked participants in a recent two-day coaching programme which part was most useful, nine of the 19 answers named practice, role play, scenarios or the activities.
That is worth understanding, because it says something about how coaching is learned.
Why it works
Coaching is a conversation skill. You can understand the theory in an afternoon and still freeze when someone sits across from you with a real problem. The gap between knowing and doing closes only through doing, ideally with someone watching who can tell you what they saw.
Role play gives you a place to fumble safely. Your first clumsy attempt at staying silent, asking an open question or resisting the urge to fix happens in a training room, not in front of your team.
Why it sometimes fails
The scenario feels made up, so people perform instead of engaging. One participant in our evaluation asked for real situations in place of invented ones.
Nobody gives feedback. Without an observer, you leave with a feeling rather than information.
There is only one attempt. The learning shows up in the second try, after you have heard what worked.
The room is too large or too crowded for everyone to take a proper turn.
How to make it real
Use real but appropriate situations. Choose a genuine work challenge that is not highly confidential or emotionally heavy. The coachee should care about the topic.
Rotate roles. In a group of three, one person coaches, one is coached and one observes. Then swap, so everyone plays every part.
Give the observer a job. Ask them to note the questions that opened the other person's thinking, the moments the coach started telling, and one thing to try next time.
Keep each round short. Ten minutes is enough to practise a full conversation and keeps the energy up.
Repeat it. Run the same type of conversation a second time and apply the feedback straight away.
Agree ground rules. What is said in practice stays in the room.
Take it back to work
The same approach works outside a training room. Ask a colleague to be your observer in your next one-to-one. Afterwards, ask them three things: what question helped most, where did I start telling, and what should I try next time. It takes five minutes and teaches you more than another book.
About the programme
About 70 per cent of our two-day coaching programme is practice and application, including simulations, role plays, coaching triads and peer feedback.
Practical Coaching & Mentoring Skills for Managers is a two-day programme from KCOM Academy, led by Rozana Halpin PCC, an ICF Professional Certified Coach, with Davidson Abishegam facilitating. To see current public dates or ask about an in-house session for your team, visit kcomacademy.com.
