
What Managers Told Us After Two Days of Coaching Practice
After every programme, KCOM Academy asks participants to complete an anonymous evaluation. We read every comment. The scores tell us whether a programme worked. The comments tell us why.
This article shares what came back from a recent two-day run of Practical Coaching & Mentoring Skills for Managers. There were 23 managers in the room and 22 completed the evaluation.
The headline numbers
Overall workshop rating: 4.55 out of 5. Twelve participants rated it Excellent and ten rated it Very good. Nobody chose Satisfactory, Fair or Poor.
Trainer star rating: 4.82 out of 5.
Knowledge of the subject, as rated by participants: 2.3 before the programme and 4.0 after.
No participant scored any question 1 or 2.
Content and delivery
Every score on content and delivery sat between 4.36 and 4.77 out of 5.
Learning objectives were clear: 4.59
Content was organised and well planned: 4.36
Course workload was appropriate: 4.50
Allowed me to participate fully: 4.64
Trainer was friendly and helpful: 4.77
Trainer was professional: 4.77
Trainer stimulated my interest: 4.68
Trainer was clear and organised: 4.59
The lowest score was for how well the content was organised, and two participants chose Neutral on it. We would rather tell you that than leave it out.
What participants valued most
Nineteen participants answered the question about the most useful part of the programme. Nine of the 19 answers named practice, role play, scenarios or the activities. Six named the GROW framework or the coaching method.
The repeated practice.
Activities on experiencing real coaching.
I believe The GROW model will help me to structure the coaching session in the future. This will lead to an effective performance evaluation session with team members and overall team effectiveness.
The third comment is about what happens after the programme, in the next performance conversation. That is the purpose of the practice.
What participants asked for
Thirteen participants gave suggestions. Four said there was nothing to change. Of the other nine:
Five asked for more time, and three of them named three days instead of two. One of the five also asked for more mentoring content.
Two asked for a better venue. One of them said the people at the back could not see the screen clearly.
One asked to practise with real situations instead of made-up ones when volunteering as the coachee.
One asked for more practice, until they felt like an expert.
What this tells you about choosing a coaching programme
Three things stand out, and they are worth looking for in any provider.
Practice carries the programme. It was the most common answer to what was most useful.
Realism matters. The one critical comment about the activities was about made-up situations. Practising on real, appropriate workplace conversations helps the learning transfer.
Time and follow-up matter. Two days builds the core skills, and some people wanted a third day. What happens in the weeks afterwards decides whether the skills stick.
About the programme
These results come from our own two-day programme, where about 70 per cent of the time goes on practice and application.
Practical Coaching & Mentoring Skills for Managers is a two-day programme from KCOM Academy, led by Rozana Halpin PCC, an ICF Professional Certified Coach, with Davidson Abishegam facilitating. To see current public dates or ask about an in-house session for your team, visit kcomacademy.com.
