KCOM Academy blog header: coaching for performance, diagnose the gap before you choose the fix

Coaching for Performance: Diagnose the Gap Before You Fix

November 04, 2026•2 min read

A team member misses a target. The instinct is to act: give a warning, arrange training, take the task away or coach them. All four can be right. All four can also be wrong. The difference is whether you understood the gap first.

Four questions to ask before you act

  1. Is it clear? Does the person know exactly what is expected, by when and to what standard? Many performance problems are expectation problems.

  2. Can they do it? Do they have the knowledge and skill? If not, they need training, advice or practice rather than a pep talk.

  3. Do they have what they need? Time, tools, information, authority and support all matter. Sometimes the person is fine and the system is the problem.

  4. Is something else in the way? Confidence, motivation, workload or personal circumstances can all affect work. You will not know unless you ask.

Match the response to the gap

  • Unclear expectations: clarify and confirm in writing.

  • Missing skill or knowledge: teach, advise or arrange training, then check progress.

  • Missing resources: remove the obstacle or escalate it.

  • Capable but stuck, unmotivated or unsure: this is where coaching helps most.

Coaching works when the person has the ability but lacks clarity, ownership or confidence. It does not replace training when the skill is missing, and it does not replace a direct instruction when safety, policy or a fixed deadline leaves no room for choice.

A worked example

A team member keeps sending reports with errors. Three managers react differently.

  • Manager A assumes carelessness and issues a warning. The real cause was an unclear template.

  • Manager B sends the person on a course. The real cause was a rushed handover.

  • Manager C starts with questions: What is happening before you send a report? What do you check? What would make it easier? The answer shows two causes, an unclear template and no time to review. Both are fixed within a week.

Ask before you tell

The quickest way to diagnose is a short conversation in which you do most of the listening. Questions such as What is getting in the way? and What would help? often reveal in ten minutes what weeks of assumptions would not.

Finish by agreeing what will change, who will do what and when you will review it. Coaching for performance is not a softer option. It is a more accurate one.

About the programme

Day 2 of our programme includes coaching during performance concerns, coaching resistant or defensive employees and real workplace simulations with rotating coaching practice.

Practical Coaching & Mentoring Skills for Managers is a two-day programme from KCOM Academy, led by Rozana Halpin PCC, an ICF Professional Certified Coach, with Davidson Abishegam facilitating. To see current public dates or ask about an in-house session for your team, visit kcomacademy.com.

Davidson Abishegam

Davidson Abishegam

Dave is an accomplished author who combines years of experience with his passion for continuous learning and personal development. With a deep understanding of leadership, communication, and team dynamics, his writings focus on transforming personal and professional growth through insightful strategies and actionable advice. As an author, Dave is known for his engaging and accessible writing style, making complex topics easy to understand and apply. His works reflect a blend of personal experience and research-driven principles, empowering readers to unlock their potential, enhance their leadership skills, and cultivate meaningful change in their personal and professional lives. Drawing from his extensive experience in coaching, training, and team-building, Dave's books provide readers with the tools they need to achieve success. His philosophy centers around building resilience, emotional intelligence, and a growth mindset, helping individuals and teams achieve sustainable progress in today's fast-paced, ever-changing world. Dave’s works serve as a roadmap for anyone looking to make a lasting impact, both personally and within their organisations. His approach to writing reflects his commitment to lifelong learning and empowering others to continuously strive for excellence in everything they do.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog